What Trader Joe’s Gets Right About UX (That Most Apps Miss)

Hey, reader!

I gained 20 pounds from eating cookies last weekend, but that’s okay. Being with the people closest to you is invaluable. When did you last take time off to surround yourself with family and friends?

Three nuggets from today’s potion:

• 92% fewer products = faster decisions — Trader Joe’s uses Hick’s Law to reduce overwhelm and boost conversions.

• Memorable > perfect — The Peak-End Rule explains why people love the experience (not just the groceries).

• Scarcity isn’t sloppy—it’s strategic — Limited stock and rotating surprises create FOMO-driven retention.

Newsletter Navigation

• The Makers Cabinet

• Potion of the Week

• Closing Thoughts

First time reading? Sign up here! You won’t regret it. 😉

The Makers Cabinet

Wyatt Feaster is whipping up the fix for the UI/UX and QA process. Enter Ralee, a solution to capture bugs and design issues in seconds. Communicate the fixes clearly to your developers — all in one place — to designs that are pixel-perfect implementations, fast. Watch the demo video here.

Want to be featured? Join the waitlist and reply with your project.

Potion of the Week

UX Laws, Psychology Tricks, and How a Grocery Store Became a Cult Brand

What if the best product designers aren't sitting behind Figma files but wearing Hawaiian shirts and stocking frozen gnocchi?

Before I built profitable products, I worked customer service. I became a human chameleon — mirroring tone, vocabulary, and energy — learning to predict what customers wanted before they did. The dirty secret nobody tells founders:

Trader Joe's isn't just a grocery store. It's a UX lab wrapped in coconut chips and profit margins that would make your investors weep with joy.

While you're drowning in A/B tests and design systems, they've built a $3.5B revenue boost without digital ads, e-commerce, or loyalty cards. That's not an accident. That's product-market fit at scale.

Here's how they do it, and what you need to steal.

Hick's Law: Fewer Choices, More Action

Trader Joe's offers 92% fewer products than your average store. They've curated, not crammed.

• 5 types of pasta sauce? That's it.

• 80% private-label = fewer decisions, less friction.

• You buy faster and feel better doing it.

Steal for your product:

• Curate like hell. I worked with a SaaS founder who cut features by 60% and saw conversions double overnight. Fewer options = faster decisions.

• Set smart defaults. Your "recommended plan" isn't a suggestion—it's where 80% of your users should land. Choose it carefully.

• Kill choice fatigue. The most profitable products I've seen show exactly one path forward at each step, not a confusing dashboard of possibilities.

Peak-End Rule: People Remember Feelings, Not Flaws

We don't recall every moment. We remember the peak and the end.

Trader Joe's gets this. That's why:

• Employees chat with you like old friends.

• You stumble on Ube Pretzels and end with a friendly smile at checkout.

• No "rewards card" guilt trips—just good vibes.

Steal for your product:

• Design one unforgettable moment. I doubled retention for a failing app by adding a single celebratory animation at the moment of first value. Users forgave everything else.

• Nail your "last touch." The exit experience matters more than your landing page. A product I advised tripled referrals by making cancellation feel like graduation, not rejection.

• Emotion beats efficiency. Your loading screen is a branding opportunity, not dead time. The most profitable products have personality when others have spinners.

Von Restorff Effect: Weird Wins Attention

You'll never forget Scandinavian Swimmers or Hold the Cone! Why? Because they don't blend in.

• Bold packaging.

• Hand-drawn signs.

• Quirky product names that make you question reality.

Steal for your product: 

• Be the weird option. Every breakout product I've helped launch had one feature competitors thought was "too much." That became the thing users couldn't shut up about.

• Make your money-maker stand out. I've watched founders hide their premium features in dropdown menus, then wonder why nobody upgrades. Make your cash cow impossible to miss.

• Launch with spectacle. Product updates aren't features—they're events. The most profitable founders I know treat version releases like album drops, not footnotes.

Scarcity & FOMO: The Psychology of "Almost Gone"

The Pumpkin Body Butter disappears. Panic. Hoard. Repeat.

That's not poor inventory planning—it's profit psychology.

• Scarcity increases perceived value and purchase urgency.

• Rotating stock fuels "treasure hunt" dopamine that builds addictive loyalty.

• Anticipation drives habit loops better than permanent availability ever could.

Steal for your product: 

• Cap your initial users. I've launched products both ways—the ones with waitlists always made more money. People fight harder for what they can't immediately have.

• Rotate your offerings. A founder I mentored tripled revenue by making their best template "available for limited time" every quarter instead of permanent.

• Create ethical urgency. The difference between manipulation and motivation is delivering actual value. Make them wait, but make it worth it.

Human-Centered Design: Why Your Chatbot Can't Replace a Smile

Trader Joe's won't do self-checkout. Why? Because humans are sticky.

• Employees walk you to items instead of pointing.

• They compliment your snack picks like they actually care.

• They turn a mundane task into a connection.

Steal for your product:

• Don't automate the money moments. I watched a founder replace live onboarding with videos and lose 70% of their conversions overnight. Some touchpoints need a pulse.

• Humanize your UX copy. The difference between a failed launch and a six-figure one is often just voice. Products that sound like people outperform products that sound like products.

• Prioritize connection over efficiency. The most successful products I've helped build make users feel seen, not just served. Recognition drives renewal more than any feature ever will.

The Hidden Genius: It's All Designed to Feel Undesigned

Here's the truth that separates wealthy founders from broke ones: Trader Joe's feels accidental. It's not. Every detail—from store size to sample tables—is engineered for your wallet.

The greatest psychological sleight-of-hand in business is making customers feel like they discovered you, not that you strategically positioned yourself in their path.

They weaponize:

• Hick's Law – Fewer options = faster money

• Peak-End Rule – Feelings outlast features

• Von Restorff Effect – Weird gets remembered and shared

• Scarcity – Temporary creates urgency

• Human Touch – Automation kills profits at key moments

Your 5-Minute Product Makeover:

Look at your product right now and ask yourself:

• Where are you overwhelming users? Cut your options in half. Now cut them again.

• What's your peak moment? If there isn't one, your product is forgettable.

• What's your "weird"? If you're playing it safe everywhere, you're invisible everywhere.

• Where's your strategic scarcity? Unlimited access means limited desire.

• What touchpoint needs a human? The moment before money changes hands.

What's Next?

Look, you're not building the next Facebook. You're building something people will actually pay for. And the secret isn't in the latest UI framework — it's in the dusty psychology textbooks nobody reads.

Need help now? I've got three slots open for 30-minute Product Teardowns next week. Reply with "TEARDOWN" and I'll send you the booking link. We'll dissect where your funnel leaks money and how to patch it using the principles from today.

Is your product suffering from "boring but functional" syndrome? Let me know your biggest conversion struggle, and I'll reply with one specific fix based on your situation.

I'll go first: my biggest struggle was thinking clever features matter more than clever psychology. They don't. Psychology always wins.

P.S. The founders who reply to this email tend to be the ones who end up with profitable products. Just saying.

Closing Thoughts

Let’s brew something great! If you’re building a product and want to make your users fall in love with it, I’d love to help.

Book a free Discovery Call — We’ll talk through what’s working, what’s not, and how to turn user experience into serious growth.

Catch you next week 👋

— Dana

P.S. I take replies seriously. If you’re stuck on something: UX, growth, or clarity — I might turn it into a full-blown breakdown (free consulting? Kinda).