Hey, {{first_name | product-preneur}}!
Most founders (even designers) think they have a homepage problem.
Guess what? They don't. They have a wrong buyer problem.
I just went through four homepages in a deathmatch: Gamma, Notion, Beehiiv, and HubSpot. And the signal is the same every time. Your CTA, your proof, your first visual. They're either pulling in the right person or sitting in the dark like a silent murderer telling them to leave.
So let's talk about what you're copying when you build, and whether you actually should be. You might be surprised.
Brewers' Bulletin
🎥 Last week on YouTube: I audited 10 Product Hunt startups, and they all had the same 5 revenue leaks. Have you seen this pattern? Watch now!
📒 The Leak Ledger: Every week, I audit three real products from Product Hunt and score them across five UX and conversion categories. Free, delivered every Friday. View now!
Potion of the Week
The CTA is the most honest thing on any homepage. "Start free" means one person can decide. "Book a demo" means there's a committee behind that purchase.
That one button tells you everything about who the product was built to convert.
And if you're using AI or vibe coding to spin up a homepage from reference sites, you're probably not thinking about who those sites were actually built for. You're just putting a cute little suit on a scarecrow. Looks great. Converts nobody.
Matchup 1: Gamma vs Notion
Gamma shows the output. Notion earns the abstraction. Know which one you are.
Gamma shows you the finished result before you finish reading the first sentence. Above the fold there's an actual styled presentation right next to the headline. Not a feature description, but the output.
Your brain doesn't have to imagine what you'd get because you can already see it. Every product category works the same way. If your product creates something, show the finished thing before you explain the engine.
Notion is doing something different. "Meet the night shift." If I landed on that like a cold hotdog as a solo founder, my gut reaction would be… “okay cool, night shift, agents," but what does this actually make for me?”
It works because it's Notion. 100M users, $600M ARR. They've earned the right to be abstract. Scroll down and you hit a wall of Fortune 500 logos. Trusted by 98% of the Forbes Cloud 100. For a VP evaluating tools, that's reassurance.
For a solo founder, that tells you you're in the wrong room. There's even a savings calculator on the page. Default team size? Ten. This section was not built with one person in mind.
Wrong proof is worse than no proof. It tells the right person they're somewhere they don't belong.
Matchup 2: Beehiiv vs HubSpot
Similar category. Different buyer. The button order tells you everything.
Beehiiv knows exactly who it's talking to and says it in five words. "Powering the internet's best newsletters." Testimonials aren't from enterprise VPs, they're from creators and publishers. Someone your buyer actually sees themselves in.
Every pricing tier says “try for free.” The enterprise option exists but it's a tiny footnote at the very bottom. The whole page is designed for you to get in the door without friction.
HubSpot sure as hell is not seducing me as a solo founder. The big solid orange button says "Get a demo." The free option is smaller, secondary. Their case study tabs: Enterprise, Mid-Sized Business, then Small Business, in that order, with Enterprise already selected by default. You didn't even need to read the case studies. The tab order told you who this was built for.
This is not a hit piece on HubSpot. Their homepage is doing exactly what it should for their buyer. The problem is when solo founders copy it without realizing the person it was built to convert looks nothing like them.
Three checks before you rebuild anything.
Does your CTA match how your buyer actually decides?
Is your proof from someone your buyer wants to become?
Does your first visual show the result, or make them imagine it?
Every second your visitor spends imagining what your product does is a second closer to bouncing. Be careful who you copy. They did the research. They did it for their buyer. Not yours.
Want me to find exactly where your product is leaking revenue? That is the Revenue Leak Map. 👇
Corking Things Up
Pull up your homepage right now. Look at your CTA. "Start free" or "book a demo?" More importantly, does it match how your buyer actually decides?
Drop it in a reply or comment. I'll tell you if it's working against you.
👋 I’ll see ya next week! — Dana
P.S. If you enjoy my emails, move them to your primary inbox and let me know by sending a reply or clicking the poll below.
